Oak Harbor Lake Community

Community Features & Guidelines

  • 30 acre boutique lake community comprised of 12 building lots.
  • Shares southern border with 750-acre Taughannock Falls State Park, ensuring privacy and serenity.

  • Property is a nature lovers paradise, home to many animal species including white-tail deer, turkey, red fox, loon, and a long-time resident red-tailed hawk & featuring a variety of mature trees.

  • Effortless year-round accessibility offered by broad, town-owned and maintained road; directly off NYS Route 89.

  • Neighborhood nature trail leads to ravine overlook area—a great spot for mid-day picnic.

  • Community members and guests share almost 300’ of lakefront with large grass lawn, stone sea-wall and large T-shape deck.

  • Property owners have the option to install a covered boat hoist.

  • Attractive community entrance with professional landscaping and signage.

  • Community Sunrise pavilion with benches offers breathtaking views.

  • Common area parking lot at beach access point.

  • Water accessible via sturdy stairway or gravel golf cart path.

  • Reasonable HOA fees (currently $169/month) and regular meetings with the lowest tax-rate in Tompkins Co. ($26.34/1000 for 2019).

  • Five minutes from the quaint Village of Trumansburg with eateries, a robust farmers market, shops, and professional services.

  • Close proximity to many area employers including: Cayuga Medical Center (15 minutes), Ithaca College (25 minutes), Cornell University (27 minutes) and Borg Warner (30 minutes).

Available Properties

Oak Harbor Lot 1

Represented by Licensed Salesperson, Havana Jorin, Lot 1 already has a drilled well and a distant lake view. Located on your left hand side as you first enter the community from Taughannock Blvd.


Survey Map

Oak Harbor Lot 4

Bordering Taughannock Falls State Park to the North, this 1.47 acre building site boasts 200' of road frontage. Partially wooded and centrally located within development. Roughly 200 yards to beach parking area and sunrise pavilion.


Survey Map


Oak Harbor Lot 10

Terrific building site in the center of the community. At 1.95 acres this is the 2nd largest home site still available. Enjoy a peak-a-boo of the lake with proper site design and planning.


Survey Map


5224 Oak Harbor Road

Represented by Licensed R.E. Salesperson Jamie Yaman

Lot 12
5224 Oak Harbor Road, Trumansburg, NY

Over 3500 sq ft on three levels. Main level custom master suite with private balcony and walk-in closet. Great room with stone hearth fireplace and soaring ceilings with cascading windows allowing for an abundance of natural light and views of the lake.


Recently Sold Residential on Oak Harbor

Custom contemporary home built of quality post and beam construction and natural design elements including locally-sourced stone fireplace, southern yellow pine and wrought iron accents


Built by:

Woodhouse TImber Fram Company


Watch this video to learn more

Why the Finger Lakes?

Kathleen Seaman
Ithaca Village Office